Homemade Cool Whip

So many of my readers don’t have Cool Whip available to them or opt not to use the product for nutrition reasons. This homemade substitute will work perfectly in place of Cool Whip in any recipe!

Homemade Cool Whip | www.somethingswanky.com

I love Cool Whip. It’s my very favorite ingredient at just about any given time, and I use it constantly in dessert-making. But whenever I post a recipe that uses Cool Whip, I brace myself for the onslaught of comments I’ll get that go something like this:

“We don’t have Cool Whip in Australia/Britain/XYZ! So sad I can’t make this!”

or, the ever popular… “I don’t eat Cool Whip because it’s so processed/fake/unhealthy/straight-up-poison. Can I use regular whipped cream instead?” (99% of the time, the answer is NO, by the way)

I hate posting a great recipe knowing that a portion of my readers can’t or won’t be able to make it, because it contains Cool Whip!

Homemade Cool Whip | www.somethingswanky.com

I’ve wanted to make a homemade substitution for a long time, but it seemed like such a daunting task! Where to even start??

Recently I came across Tidy Mom’s Salted Caramel Cheesecake (*drool*) garnished with stable whipped cream. Genius.

I made a few minor tweaks and additions, and I think it’s a pretty great substitute for Cool Whip in recipe.

Homemade Cool Whip | www.somethingswanky.com

MAJOR DISCLOSURE: this is an awesome substitute for Cool Whip, but it does not taste EXACTLY the same. It tastes just like regular whipped cream (you can see how the consistency looks like whipped cream instead of Cool Whip), but it holds up just like Cool Whip does. This makes it ideal for topping cakes or using it in a mousse or salad recipe just as you would use Cool Whip.

One of the major testing factors that was important to me was how it would stand up to being mixed into pudding to create a mousse. I figured that was a pretty good overall test of it’s stability since you are incorporating it completely into another semi-liquid. Happily, it worked out amazingly! The mousse tasted delicious (and just like it does when I use Cool Whip), and there were no signs of deflation or watery mess after 24 hours:

Homemade Cool Whip | www.somethingswanky.com

Important notes about this recipe:

  • Don’t skip dissolving the cream of tartar in the plastic bag. It’s the best way I’ve found to keep the cream of tartar from clumping (yuck).
  • I’ve tried every which way to skip the stove top part of this process. But unless you want clumps of gelatin in your whipped cream, you have to dissolve it in the hot water over the stove, and then let it cool down before adding it to the whipping cream.
  • Be sure not to over-mix during the whisking process. You shouldn’t try for stiff peaks– you’ll just end up with a curdled mess (albeit a yummy one). Once the cream is thick enough to spread, stop whisking. It will still look soft, but that’s okay.
  • Store covered in the refrigerator, just like you would Cool Whip. I was overly anxious to post this recipe, and I didn’t wait to find out what this recipe’s shelf life is. I will update as soon as I know!

Homemade Cool Whip

Ingredients

  • 1/4 cup cold water
  • 1 teaspoon unflavored gelatin
  • 1/2 teaspoon cream of tartar
  • 1 3/4 cups whipping cream
  • 3 tablespoons sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla

Instructions

  1. Pour the water into a small saucepan. Sprinkle the gelatin over the water, and let it sit for 2-3 minutes. Place the pan over medium-low heat and stir until gelatin dissolves. Remove from heat and let cool completely.
  2. Once the gelatin mixture has cooled...
  3. Place 1 tablespoon of the whipping cream and the cream of tartar in a small ziptop bag. Seal the bag and shake it until cream of tartar has dissolved completely and there are no lumps. If there are lumps, use your fingers to work them out.
  4. Pour the cream of tartar mixture into a large bowl (the bowl of your mixer if using a stand mixer) along with the rest of the whipping cream and the sugar.
  5. Beat with a hand mixer or the whisk attachment on a stand mixer on medium speed for about 2 minutes. Once cream mixture begins to slightly thicken, slowly pour in the gelatin-water while continually mixing. Add the vanilla.
  6. Continue to mix until the cream is thick and smooth.
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin
http://www.somethingswanky.com/homemade-cool-whip/

 

 

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Comments

  1. And this is why you are a such a good food blogger :) I don’t know that I would have had the patience for this task!
    Lisa @ Wine & Glue recently posted..Eggnog CheesecakeMy Profile

  2. YOU DID IT!!! This is amazing!!!! For anyone who doesn’t have it (and the rare occasions when I post about it, I get a zillion emails), I know where to send them! pinned

  3. Excellent stabilized whipped cream recipe, Ashton! Glad you tested in recipes calling for Cool Whip with success. However, in your Notes above the recipe, you mention cornstarch. Is cornstarch missing from the recipe? I don’t see it in the ingredients list or in the instructions. Or, did you mean cream of tartar when you mentioned cornstarch? Thanks for sharing!

  4. Your cousin in Grenada is grateful for the post! I may have missed this in the post but how much does it yield? The same as a full container of Cool Whip?

  5. Wow – this is pretty great – thanks!
    Jenn@eatcakefordinner recently posted..My Malibu ChickenMy Profile

  6. This is genius! Thanks for sharing :)
    Laura @ Lauras Baking Talent recently posted..Chocolate Mint BrowniesMy Profile

  7. THANK YOU!!!!!!!

  8. You are a HERO! I’m allergic to coconut so I can’t eat cool whip. There are so many different recipes I haven’t been able to try because I didn’t have a substitute. Now I do – thanks!

  9. I have used stabilized whipped cream many times before but never thought of tweeking it for a cool whip substitute, u are amazing!!! I’m in S. Korea and sometimes, especially close to a major holiday, there is a shortage of commonly used goods. I’m definitely saving and printing this one! Thanks a bunch!

  10. My mind is blown. I am seriously itching to make this RIGHT NOW! Heck yeah!
    Katrina @ In Katrina’s Kitchen recently posted..Candy Cane (Peppermint) Simple SyrupMy Profile

  11. I just saw a recipe for stabilized whipped cream that I’ve been dying to try. I turned into a whipped cream snob after I started blogging and now I don’t use Cool Whip very often. But there have been a couple recipes that REALLY didn’t work with whipped cream, like mousse. Now I know what to do! (Or just go buy Cool Whip) ;) Thanks for testing this out for us!
    Nicole recently posted..Let’s Get Real #16My Profile

  12. You are amazing! Genius idea :)
    Mandy’s Recipe Box recently posted..Crispy Maple Sugar CookiesMy Profile

  13. Yay, Yay, Yay. You sweet Asthon are the best!

    Thank you, thank you, thank you.

    Christmas just came early for me. Totally made my day

    happy dance currently happening!!! Holla, so very excited (just in case you missed it ;))

    Thank you thank you thank you xoxoxoxoox
    Emma recently posted..Cranberry Raspberry Lime Iced TeaMy Profile

  14. Great idea and post. I likewise avoid as many processed foods as possible, but I certainly would never complain to the blogger for using them. I just skip those recipes for us, or pass them on to my daughters who need quick and convenient everything. Thanks!

  15. I hear angels singing! This is the best thing I’ve read all day… thank you!!
    Jennifer recently posted..Twenty One Days – Photos and a Few Links to ShareMy Profile

  16. Am I safe in assuming this can be frozen, so I can have it on hand “just like Cool-Whip”?
    Thanks for the recipe.

  17. LIFECHANGER

  18. This is so cool! I wish I knew how to make it so it is French Vanilla “Cool Whip”! I love that stuff and the stores around me never have it. It is aggravating!

  19. You are a genius! Thanks for sharing. By the way, what font are you using on your pictures now?
    Jodi recently posted..My Favorite Gingersnaps {12 Days of Sugar ~ Day 5}My Profile

  20. You’re a freaking genius. LOVE.
    Dorothy @ Crazy for Crust recently posted..Peanut Butter SnickerdoodlesMy Profile

  21. I’m kinda one of those people that’s all eww gross Cool Whip so I love this! Genius recipe!
    Laura Dembowski recently posted..Easy Almond Butter FudgeMy Profile

  22. THANK YOU! I used to use Cool Whip all.the.time! Until I found out what was in it. Eww!!! So, Thank you for sharing this recipe! Excited to try it out!

  23. I love making Pretzel Jello Salad, but my boyfriend hates processed foods like Cool Whip, so maybe he’ll eat it if I use this instead! Thanks for the recipe!
    Jen @ Fresh From The… recently posted..Supernatural 9×09 “Holy Terror”My Profile

  24. Does it make a difference whether you use granulated sugar or powdered sugar? I’m one of those people who don’t eat Cool Whip because of the scary ingredients and the all-natural version doesn’t work well in recipes. Thanks so much for this!

  25. This recipe is so cool. Need to ask, have you ever tried it using milk? My husband has problems with lactose. and has to use lactose free milk. I’m trying a way to get around the cream so he can enjoy whipped topping on pumpkin pie.
    II hope this comes through clearly because the text is not clear for me.

  26. Sarah Willoughby says:

    OMG!!!!!! COOL WHIP!!!!!! I can’t believe it!!!!! I haven’t had cool whip since I was a little girl. You can’t buy it here in the UK woe is me :’-( I was born in the states, in Maine, but lived here in UK since I was three. my father is from London and my mother is also from Maine and was in the US Navy and stationed in London so I only got to have cool whip at thanksgiving and Christmas with pumpkin pie when she would shop at the base and stock up on US goods. Once she left the Navy we also had to say goodbye to all the American goodies including peanut butter and chocolate! Which people over here are only just discovering! Also peanut butter and jelly/jam is viewed with suspicion which I found to be second nature to put together! So sorry for going on but thank you so much for this recipe, finally another goodie I can make at home and can no longer be a distant memory.

  27. Ashton – you are truly amazing!
    Heather @ French Press recently posted..Chocolate Hazelnut Crepes and Hot CocoaMy Profile

  28. Absolutely genius Ashton! I will definitely be trying it!
    Lindsay @ Life, Love and sugar recently posted..Gingerbread Caramel Gooey BarsMy Profile

  29. Jessica Donohue says:

    I love this!!! If anyone asks about a gelatin substitute (you may get this question down the road, hopefully not), you can use Agar flakes. It’s a seaweed derivative. I used it in making homemade American cheese and it worked pretty well. Very cool! Thanks for figuring this out.

  30. While this works, it is unnecessarily difficult. You can use 1/2 to 3/4 teaspoon of cornstarch for each cup of heavy cream. Add it with the sugar and it will stabilize the cream quite easily and nicely. You can buy packages of Oetker’s stabilizer for whipped cream (Or maybe Dr. Oetkers I forget what the package said as it has been a few decades since I bought it.) and it is cornstarch and an anticaking agent. I have used this for every recipe that calls for cool whip for over twenty years and never once did it fail me.

    • Awesome tip! I’ll have to try that!

      • Angie Scheie says:

        My husband is allergic to corn and is it extremely difficult to find things without it so I greatly appreciate its non use in your recipe;). As a side note, how long to do find yourself wisking/beating until it thickens up. Mine does not seem to be doing so:(

  31. This makes me a happy girl :) been wanting a good substitute for a while. Thank you! I love your recipes! My hubby gets so happy when I make your brownies.

  32. this sounds interesting but I have a question. You say that you cannot usually substitute whipped cream for cool whip. Why would that be? I’ve never had problems with the substitution, but maybe I haven’t been making the kind of dishes that are a problem. Also, do you know what the cream of tartar does for the mixture? I’ve used it to sour milk as a buttermilk substitute. Does this need the acidity, also?

    • In many of my recipes that use cool whip, it is an integral part of the recipe– not just a topping. So whipped cream tends to deflate in those, which is why you need a stable whipped cream.

  33. Can you use this in a recipe that calls for you to fold cool whip into cream cheese? I make a pudding dessert that has a shortbread style crust, a cream cheese/cool whip layer, a pudding layer, and then cool whip on top. I haven’t made it for a while because of the guilt I feel when using cool whip.

  34. THANK YOU!!! I’ve missed having cool whip after moving to london a decade ago. Finally I can make ‘funeral salad’ again ;-)

  35. What a life saviour! How much does this make though?

  36. Katie Short says:

    Thank you so much! This is awesome… so very pinned

  37. Christine Meier says:

    My question is can I use Stevia in place of the sugar? I am lo-carbing it and although it is not much sugar I just wondered if anyone had tried it before

  38. Kari Masoner says:

    Thank you for sharing this recipe… I’m in the camp that doesn’t want to use Cool Whip because of the ingredients… I thank you from the bottom of my heart for your work in creating a substitute… (I haven’t tried it yet, but will soon.)

  39. This is great! I have found so many nice recipes which includes Cool Whip and I can’t get here in Finland. Now I can start baking! Awesome! Thanks a tons for this recipe!

  40. Just wondering if this would hold up for piping on top of a pie or cake and also as a spread between layers of a cake….thank you so much!

  41. Jane Faulkner says:

    I used to make a frozen peanut butter pie using cool whip. Can your version be frozen please?

  42. Wonder if it works with half and half cream-to save a few calories?

  43. Bianca Majewski says:

    I love cool whip but we don’t have it in Germany. :-(
    So can’t wait to try this recipe. Thanks

  44. Thank you so much for all your hard work that you’ve put into this project. I live in Australia and have coeliac disease – as you previously mentioned there are so many desert recipes that I couldn’t make. Now thanks to you I can try a lot more recipes. Keep up the great work

  45. Jessica says:

    Thanks so much for this! Where I live we don’t have Cool Whip either so I’ll have to give this a try! Thanks!!

  46. Rita Gallo says:

    The cool whip sounds great– I don`t use store bought because of the ingredients– Am patiently waiting to hear if anyone has had any luck freezing it

  47. Marisa Micallef says:

    Thanks a million, if you were here i would hug and kiss you !!!
    will try it for sure as soon as i have some time and will pass it on to my sister Anna who usually uses cool whip while in PEI but did not know what to use when in Malta! Once again thanks a million times over. xxx

  48. Hate to be a p.i.a. but would cornstarch sub for the cream of tartar? In Spain that is something that I can’t get. Dying to try it!!!

  49. Emma Argo says:

    Just made this, It tastes delicious, but why do I have chunks of gelatin?

  50. Hi there
    Any update on the storage life for this yet? I’d like to use it for a cake for a party on 11th oct and wondering how far in advance I can make it :-)
    thanks!

Leave a Comment

*

Current ye@r *

CommentLuv badge