Nutter Butter S’mores Magic Cookie Bars

Nutter Butter S'mores Magic Bars on #recipes #dessert

First off, I’d like to send a big hug to everyone in Boston tonight. What a truly despicable thing to happen, and my thoughts, prayers, and sympathy is with all of you who may need it tonight.

In view of today’s happenings in Boston as well as my recent move and unpacking frenzy, tonight’s post will be (understandably, I hope) brief! Fortunately, all you need to know about this recipe is pretty basic:

These bars are an amalgamation of two of my favorite desserts from last year: S’moreo Magic Bars and Nutter Butter S’mores Ice Cream. And they are every bit as good as they look!

Nutter Butter S'mores Magic Bars on #recipes #dessert

Nutter Butter S’mores Magic Cookie Bars


  • 15 Nutter Butter Cookies (1 1/2 cups), crushed
  • 3 Tbsp. butter
  • 1 cup miniature marshmallows
  • 1 cup Hershey Milk Chocolate bars, broken into pieces
  • 1/2 cup semi sweet chocolate chips
  • 10 Nutter Butters, crumbled
  • 14.5 oz can sweetened condensed milk


  1. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Prepare an 8x8 baking dish by lining it with parchment paper and spraying lightly with a nonstick cooking spray.
  2. Pulse the Nutter Butter and butter in a food processor or blender until cookies are crushed and mixed well with the butter.
  3. Press the crumbs well into the bottom of the dish. Bake the crust for 10 minutes.
  4. Remove crust from the oven and top with marshmallows (FIRST), Hershey bars, chocolate chips, and crumbled Nutter Butters. Pour the sweetened condensed milk evenly over the top.
  5. Bake for 45 minutes until the top is golden and edges are bubbly. It should feel somewhat set when you push it, even though it will be melted and gooey.
  6. Let cool completely before cutting and serving.
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin

Magic Bars from Friends:

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.


  1. Dru @ Teenage Cakeland says:

    I was just craving Nutter Butters! These bars look incredible omg. Prayers to Boston :(

  2. Oh my gosh! Nutella, marshmallow, chocolate and nutter butters, I couldn’t think of a better combination!
    Julianne @ Beyond Frosting recently posted..Gluten-Free S’mores CupcakesMy Profile

  3. Anything s’mores is so great!
    Nancy P.@thebittersideofsweet recently posted..Crockpot GiveawayMy Profile

  4. I’ve never had a 7 layer bar before and I’ve been wanting to try some and looking for the perfect recipe, so this post came at a perfect time! Nutter Butters and chocolate in a gooey bar form? Yes please!
    Faith @ Pixie Dust Kitchen recently posted..Apple Pie TartsMy Profile

  5. What a fantastically delicious magic bar!
    Erin @ The Spiffy Cookie recently posted..Hot Oat & Quinoa CerealMy Profile

  6. Oh my goodness…I haven’t had nutter butters in forever, but I HAVE to make these! amazing pictures Ashton, and I hope you are getting settled:)
    Heather @ French Press recently posted..Flourless {dark chocolate} BrowniesMy Profile

  7. These look insanely gooey!
    Hopefully you’re having fun settling into your new home and have found your cookie sheets :)
    Loretta | A Finn In The Kitchen recently posted..Peanut Butter Cheesecake Layer BrowniesMy Profile

  8. Yum. Pinning.
    Shiloh Barkley recently posted..Squash CasseroleMy Profile

  9. Yeah, no disputes here! Love love love these, Ashton. Peanut butter + s’mores is such a winning combo!
    Hayley @ The Domestic Rebel recently posted..Strawberry Shortcake Egg RollsMy Profile

  10. We’re having a party and I think these would be a great hit. All the right stuff to make a delicious bar. Hope you can drop by with the recipe.

    Linda recently posted..Edit page HTML for WowSliderMy Profile

  11. Totally amazing. And guess what dessert I was brainstorming yesterday afternoon? Yup. These. lol Yours are way better!
    Dorothy @ Crazy for Crust recently posted..Avocado Chicken Salad SandwichesMy Profile

  12. Holy cow! These look AMAZING!!! Love Nutter Butters and S’mores! What a scrumptious combo! Pinned ;) Thanks for sharing!

  13. This just looks so incredible, I seriously almost have no words. What a great combo! So sticky and gooey and delish looking!

  14. Wow, these look so good. Can’t wait to make them :-)

  15. These look so good, Ashton! All the layers, flavors, gooey factor. Everything is a big win in these babies!
    Averie @ Averie Cooks recently posted..Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Scotchies CookiesMy Profile

  16. Oh man, these look amazing!! Any tips for a Nutter Butter substitute? I live in Canada and don’t have easy access to them. :(

    • ANY peanut butter cookie would do– but if you could find a sandwich type cookie, that would be best! I’ve done this same thing with Oreos, and it’s amazing!

  17. Just pinned, my kids will love these!
    capturing joy with kristen duke recently posted..Back to School Shopping Style with TargetMy Profile

  18. Oh WOW! I have to try this… Thanks for sharing.

  19. Maybe I did something wrong but at 38mins at 350 the whole dish is bubbly and chocolate is melted everywhere. Ideas?

  20. I have the mini (bite size) Nutter Butters. Any idea of how much I should use for each section of this recipe?


  1. [...] Nutter Butter S’mores Magic Cookie Bars [...]

  2. [...] Nutter Butter S’mores Magic Cookie Bars by Something Swanky [...]

  3. [...] Samoas Inspired Ghirardelli S’mores Nutter Butter S’mores Magic Cookie Bars [...]

  4. [...]  S’mores Sandwich Bar Cookies from She Knows *  S’more Crescent Rolls from Mess for Less *  Nutter Butter S’mores Magic Cookie Bars from Something Swanky *  S’moredillas from That’s So Yummy *  S’mores Stuffed Rice Krispie Treats from Love From [...]

  5. [...] out some of my other S’mores Recipes!Nutter Butter S’mores Magic BarsOoey Gooey Butter S’mores CookiesNutter Butter S’mores [...]

Leave a Comment


Current ye@r *

CommentLuv badge