Thanksgiving Oreo Cake Recipe You’ll Love for Dessert

My favorite chocolate cake recipe filled with cream cheese frosting and an outside layer of chocolate buttercream with cute little Oreo Turkeys that make this cake perfect for Thanksgiving! If you’re searching for a thanksgiving oreo cake recipe that’s both easy and totally show-stopping, be still my heart, you have found it.

You’ll also love my Chocolate Chess Pie for Thanksgiving!

I feel like I’ve been baking pumpkin and fall and cinnamon apples for months and months now, and I still haven’t shared all the Fall recipes rattling around in my brain! Somehow there’s never enough time. These days, “enough time” is a sort of abstract unicorn of an idea I’m not sure ever actually exists. I wake up, I work out, and I — BOOM! It’s 4:00 and it’s carpool and dinner prep and dishes (so many dishes) and bath and bed and then I’m passed out on the couch. Does anybody else’s day work like that? You’re nodding your head, right?

Anyway. In all the madness of normal life lately, I decided I really wanted to make this Oreo Turkey Cake, because we’re not all pie people, you know? I mean, I am, and I think all normal sane human beings are, but I hear stories of people who don’t like pie. So on the slim possibility that might be true, I figured a thanksgiving dessert in cake form was in order. This is hands down one of the best ways to win over a crowd at special occasions, and it’s a genuinely perfect celebration cake for the holiday table.

And what a cake it is! Isn’t she a beaut??

Why This Thanksgiving Oreo Cake Recipe Works

And you guys — this cake is really super easy, and that’s exactly why it’s become one of my go-to oreo cake recipe ideas for busy holiday weeks. I can’t even begin to tell you what a rush I was in the day I made this cake. I had people coming over for dinner in less than an hour, the sun was basically down, and the dishes and frosting were flying around my kitchen like nobody’s business. It was cray-cray, y’all. But look! It’s still so cute. The moral of the story is: if I can pull this off when my day is a complete mess, you totally can too. Unlike some older recipes that demand a kitchen scale, a dozen bowls, and an entire afternoon, this one keeps things simple without sacrificing that rich oreo flavor everyone’s after.

My favorite part of the cake? Here’s a hint: it’s not the turkeys. It’s that creamy, delicious cream cheese filling! I could eat that with a spoon, you guys. And okay, yeah, fine, I did. Also, you are not going to find a more delicious, moist chocolate cake. This is the real deal, folks, with a moist crumb of the layers that honestly rivals any bakery version. If you love this one, you’ll probably also fall hard for my Chocolate Wasted Cake or my Black Velvet Cake — both total showstoppers for oreo lovers and chocolate lovers alike.

Tips For Building The Perfect Oreo Cake Layers

A few quick tips before you dive in. First, make sure your dairy — sour cream, cream cheese, and eggs — is at room temperature before you start mixing; it makes a dramatically smoother cake batter and helps the dry ingredients incorporate without overmixing. Use an electric mixer or the bowl of a stand mixer on medium speed to cream your butter and sugar until pale and fluffy, then add egg whites a little at a time for good measure. I like using two 8-inch cake tins lined with parchment paper so the layers release clean every single time. Once your layers of moist chocolate cake are baked and completely cool, use a serrated knife to level the tops before stacking. A little hot water whisked into the cocoa powder (bonus points for black cocoa powder if you have it) deepens that classic chocolate oreo cake flavor beautifully.

Making The Oreo Filling And Frosting

For the cream filling, crush a sleeve of classic cookies in a food processor until you’ve got fine crumbs, then fold them into your cream cheese frosting for that irresistible cream flavor in every bite. This oreo filling is basically a cream cake lover’s dream — tangy, sweet, and loaded with chocolate cookie crumbs. When you’re ready to frost, spread a generous layer on the first cake layer, add the next cake layer on top, and repeat. For the best oreo buttercream frosting, beat butter, icing sugar, heavy cream, and vanilla together until silky, then fold in a few soaked oreos for extra texture. Fit a piping bag with your favorite tip to pipe decorative swirls around the top of the cake and sides of the cake, and don’t skip the large chunks of whole oreo cookies or mini oreos pressed on top for aesthetic purposes — it makes the whole thing look so much more impressive than it actually is to make.

Storing And Serving Your Soft Oreo Cake

Once frosted, keep your frosted cake loosely covered or tucked into an airtight container in the fridge, and let it sit at room temperature for about 20 minutes before serving so the decadent layers of oreo cake soften back up. This cake also freezes beautifully — just wrap individual slices well. Use a sharp knife (dip it in hot water between cuts for the cleanest small slices) and set each piece on a wire rack briefly if you’ve got extra ganache to let drip down the sides of the cake. For best results, slice the entire cake with a steady hand and serve chilled but not cold — that’s when the oreo flavor and fudgy crumb really shine. Oreo lovers and cream lover types alike go nuts over this one.

Fun Variations On This Oreo Cake Recipe

Once you’ve mastered this recipe, it’s a great idea to play around with flavors. Swap in a vanilla cookie flavor cream filling for a lighter take, or go full dessert-mashup with a cinnamon toast crunch cake spin using crushed cereal in the frosting. Peanut butter lovers can swirl a spoonful into the filling for a salty-sweet twist, and if you’re feeling extra festive, press a few candy corn pieces around the base for a playful autumn touch. A dark chocolate ganache drip poured over the top of the cake takes it from homemade to bakery-level in about five minutes flat, and a lollipop stick or two tucked into a slice makes for an adorable cake-pop-style garnish for little ones. However you dress it up, this is still, at its heart, a decadent layers of oreo cake situation, and it never disappoints. For more cookies-and-cream inspiration, check out my Cookies & Cream Stuffed Cupcakes or this dreamy Cookies & Cream Pudding Mousse.

First Time Making This? Read This First

If this is your first time attempting a layered oreo cake recipe, don’t stress — this is genuinely an easy recipe once you get your ingredients organized. Measure everything with a proper measuring cup, keep an eye on your oven temperature, and use an offset spatula to get smooth sides of the cake before decorating. Scroll down to the recipe card below for the full ingredients list, exact measurements, and step-by-step directions. I’ve gotten rave reviews and only critiques along the lines of “can I have more,” so I feel pretty confident calling this a great recipe worth keeping in your back pocket for every holiday from now on. And honestly? A slice of this alongside cream ice cream is the perfect way to end any Thanksgiving dinner.

So HAPPY THANKSGIVING to all you pie-hating freaks peeps out there. Enjoy your cake!

Oreo Turkey Thanksgiving Cake

Save this recipe for later: Save Pin Add to Google

My favorite chocolate cake recipe filled with cream cheese frosting and an outside layer of chocolate buttercream with cute little Oreo Turkeys that make this cake perfect for Thanksgiving!

Print

Ingredients

• 1 chocolate cake, baked in 2 round cake tins and cooled
• 1 recipe cream cheese frosting
• 1 recipe chocolate buttercream
• Chocolate sprinkles
• 11 Oreo cookies
• candy corn for the feathers
• candy eyes
• candy coated sunflower seeds (or similarly shaped sprinkles) for the beak and feet

Instructions

Assemble the cake by spreading a thick layer of cream cheese frosting between the two layers of chocolate cake.

Frost the outside of the cake with the chocolate buttercream and add chocolate sprinkles to the bottom half if desired (I cup the sprinkles in my hand and gently press them to the side of the cake immediately after frosting).

You can pipe around the perimeter of the top of the cake like I did if you want, but most importantly pipe a large "pile" of frosting in the very center of the cake to prop up three turkeys.

Place 8 Oreo cookies around the outside of the cake, securing them with buttercream. Pipe and arc of buttercream over the top half of each oreo, and stick the candy corn in the buttercream to look like tail feathers.

Pipe three dots of buttercream in the center of each oreo to "glue" on the eyes and beak. Adhere feet in the same way.

Repeat the construction of three turkeys on top of the cake, propped against the mound of frosting in the middle.

You can store this cake at room temp or in the fridge.