Tagalong Dip posted by Staff Writer Pin Share Tweet Email Jump to Recipe If you already love Tagalongs, you’re going to love this dip! If you haven’t had Tagalongs (WHAT!?!?!), this Tagalong Dip will change your life. I loved it when Shelly from Cookies and Cups said, “You come here and you know what you’re going to get. That’s comforting.” I have to echo her sentiment, and say… No surprises here today. I made dip. Again. Again. But Tagalong Dip is awesome. …and it probably won’t be the last time 🙂 Continue to Content Tagalong Dip Print Ingredients 1/2 c. Peanut Butter 8 oz. Cream Cheese 2 c. Powdered Sugar 1-2 Tbsp. Milk Approx. 10 Tagalong Cookies (Keebler or Oreo substitutes work too) Instructions In a stand mixer, whisk together the cream cheese and the peanut butter until smooth.Gradually add in the powdered sugar and milk, alternately, whisking in between additions.Switch to a paddle attachment. Add in the Tagalong cookies and mix on high, until cookies are broken up really well and incorporated.Serve with apples or graham crackers.
Oh man. Imagine apples and frozen bananas and cookies and crackers and pretzels and all sorts of yummy things, all dippable in this stuff. You’re a master, woman! Reply
You’ve done it again Ashton. Super delicious. Something I know I can’t live without, even though I never knew it existed. 🙂 Reply
Ooh, this looks so good! I love dips. Everything just tastes so much better if you can dip it in something.Shiloheverydaygameplan.net Reply
This looks so delicious! Can’t wait to try it!Ann @ Suburban Prairie Homemakerhttp://www.suburbanprairiehomemaker.com Reply
What could I use instead of Oreos? I’m thinking vanilla wafers? Chocolate chips? I’m wanting to make it for Biblenstudy tomo. Thanks! Reply
You could really use anything, that’s the beauty of these dips! But this particular one– you could sub girl scout cookies (tagalongs, of course) or keebler’s version of tagalongs. Nutter Butters would be great since it’s a peanut butter dip… Reply
