Substitute for Butter in Icing: Picking the Best Alternative

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Are you searching for a substitute for butter in icing? You’ve stumbled upon the right page!

Many of us love the rich, creamy taste of butter in our frosting. But whether you’re vegan, lactose intolerant, or simply following a healthier diet, traditional butter might not always be a good choice.

But don’t worry, this post will provide you with some of the best frosting and buttercream recipes that use butter substitutes instead. Let’s dive in!

butter on a plate

Understanding the Role of Butter in Icing

Before we jump into the butter substitute, let’s understand why we use butter in the first place. Butter contributes to the rich flavor, creamy texture, and perfect frosting consistency.

It also helps in creating a fluffy frosting that holds its shape when piped onto a cake. Its higher fat content and lower water content compared to other ingredients ensure that the frosting doesn’t run off or soak into the cake layers.

Plus, real butter lends a unique flavor that is often associated with homemade frosting recipes.

Picture of a bottle of milk and a block of butter

Choosing a Substitute for Butter in Icing

When looking for a substitute for butter in icing, consider the texture, flavor, and consistency you want in your frosting. Also, think about the type of cake you’re icing. For example, a peanut butter frosting might work well on a chocolate cake, but not so much on a lemon one. You also have to be mindful of the fat content of the substitute, as this can affect the frosting’s stability and how it reacts at different temperatures.

Various butter substitutes, such as peanut butter and coconut oil, displayed on a wooden table

Coconut Oil: The Tropical Substitute

Coconut oil is a popular substitute for butter in icing, particularly for vegan buttercream. It has a similar fat content to butter and offers a smooth texture. Coconut oil has a higher melting point than butter, which is beneficial in warmer temperatures.

However, note that it imparts a mild coconut flavor, which may or may not be desired based on personal preferences.

Jar of coconut oil with a spoon resting on top

Vegetable Shortening: The Traditional Substitute

Vegetable shortening is a traditional substitute for butter in icing. It’s made from vegetable oils, has a high fat content, and a higher melting point than butter. Shortening gives a smooth and creamy texture to your frosting.

However, it can result in a slightly less flavorful frosting, so consider adding additional ingredients like pure vanilla extract or butter flavorings to enhance the taste.

Vegan Butter: The Dairy-Free Substitute

If you’re looking for a dairy-free option that closely mimics butter, vegan buttery spread like Smart Balance is a great choice. They have similar fat content to real butter, and can give your frosting the right consistency. Vegan butter also adds a butter-like flavor to your icing, making it an easy recipe for a buttercream frosting that tastes like the real deal.

Discover various unsalted butter substitutes for your baking needs. Our guide explores options from salted butter to dairy-free alternatives. Perfect your recipes!

Nut Butters: The Flavorful Substitute

Nut butters, such as almond and cashew, are also excellent substitutes for butter in icing. They add unique flavors to the frosting, making it a delicious option for cakes or cinnamon rolls. Keep in mind that nut butters have a thicker consistency, so you might need to adjust the amount of liquid-based flavoring agent or non-dairy milk to reach the desired consistency.

A jar of almond butter next to a bowl of frosting and a spatula

Cream Cheese: The Tangy Substitute

For a tangy twist to your frosting, you can use cream cheese as a substitute for butter in icing. Cream cheese icing is perfect for carrot cake, red velvet cake, and even sugar cookies. Be sure to use full-fat cream cheese for the best flavor and consistency. If you’re making a dairy-free cake, you can opt for vegan cream cheese as a substitute.

Avocado: The Healthy Substitute

Yes, you read that right. Avocado can be a healthier alternative to butter in frosting! And it is actually more common than you think to use avocado in desserts. It offers a creamy texture, much like traditional buttercream. Plus, it’s packed with healthy fats and nutrients. The flavor is mild enough to be masked by cocoa powder or vanilla extract.

So, whether you’re frosting a birthday cake or a batch of sugar cookies, avocado can be a smart substitute!

A halved avocado next to a bowl of green avocado frosting and a spatula

In Conclusion

Exploring a substitute for butter in icing opens a whole new world of flavors and textures. From coconut oil to vegan butter, and even avocado, there are numerous alternatives to choose from.

Always remember to consider the type of cake, the frosting’s consistency, and the flavors you want to bring out when choosing a butter substitute. Happy baking!

salted butter on a butter knife
« Previous Post

Substitute for White Chocolate: How to Make Delicious Substitutes

Next Post »

Our Best Lemon Dessert Recipes – A Citrus Celebration!

Leave a Comment