Brown Sugar Substitutes — and How To Make Your Own

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Brown sugar is a beloved ingredient in baking and cooking, lending its rich flavor and moist texture to countless recipes. But what if you find yourself without this pantry staple? Fear not! Whether you’ve run out of brown sugar or want a healthier alternative, there are plenty of brown sugar substitutes to keep your culinary creations sweet and satisfying.

In this blog post, we’ll explore a variety of brown sugar substitutes, from simple pantry swaps to natural and healthy alternatives. Whether you’re whipping up cookies, glazing meats, or making sauces, you’ll discover the perfect replacement for brown sugar. Let’s dive in! 🍯

brown sugar in a bowl

The Difference Between Brown Sugar and White Sugar

White Sugar, also known as granulated sugar, is made from sucrose extracted from sugar beets or refined sugar cane. The thorough processing removes molasses, resulting in a pure, colorless, and odorless crystal. White sugar is neutral and sweet, making it versatile for various recipes.

Brown Sugar has two sub-categories:

  • Light Brown Sugar: Contains a small amount of molasses, giving it a mild caramel flavor and light color.
  • Dark Brown Sugar: With double the molasses of light brown sugar, it boasts a richer, deeper flavor and a darker hue.

Moisture Content and Texture:

  • Brown sugar retains more moisture due to the molasses. Proper storage prevents it from drying out.
  • White sugar is drier and less sticky.

Baking Use:

  • Both sugars find their place in baking, but consider the recipe:
    • Swapping: Substituting brown sugar for white may affect texture (too moist) or flavor (caramel notes overpowering).
    • Texture: Brown sugar promotes a dense, chewy texture due to molasses moisture.

In summary, brown sugar’s molasses content adds flavor and moisture, while white sugar is neutral and versatile. Choose wisely for your next baking adventure! 🍰🍬

Making Your Own Brown Sugar

Making your own brown sugar is a simple and convenient solution when you’re out of this pantry staple. Whether you need light or dark brown sugar, all you need are two ingredients: granulated sugar and molasses. Here’s how to do it:

  1. Ingredients for Light Brown Sugar:
    • 1 cup granulated sugar
    • 1 1/2 tablespoons molasses
  2. Instructions:
    • In a small mixing bowl, combine the granulated sugar and molasses.
    • Mix thoroughly until the molasses is completely incorporated into the sugar. This should take about 2 to 3 minutes.
    • If you prefer dark brown sugar, add an additional tablespoon of molasses (for a total of 2 tablespoons) to the sugar.
    • Use your homemade brown sugar just like store-bought brown sugar in your recipes.

Why Make Your Own Brown Sugar? Brown sugar adds richness and depth to baked goods and other dishes. It has a softer texture and a distinct caramel flavor. Store-bought brown sugar is essentially refined sugar with added molasses. The difference between light and dark brown sugar lies in the amount of molasses added during production. Dark brown sugar has a deeper color and more pronounced caramel flavor due to its higher molasses content.

Remember, once you add the molasses, the weight of your DIY brown sugar will be very close to that of store-bought brown sugar, so you can substitute it one-for-one in recipes. Enjoy your homemade sweetener! 🍯

A sealed jar of molasses

Substitutes for Brown Sugar

There are few things worse than realizing halfway through a recipe to make the perfect chocolate chip cookie that you ran out of brown sugar.

There are many practical alternatives that you can use in a pinch, many of which you may already own in your pantry.

Coconut Sugar

Coconut sugar, derived from the sap of coconut palm trees, has become quite the buzzworthy natural sweetener. It shares some similarities with brown sugar, both in flavor and appearance. Picture a rich, caramel-like taste that pairs beautifully with baked goods and other treats. On the other side of the sugar bowl, we have brown sugar—a classic ingredient made by adding molasses back to refined white sugar. Brown sugar brings its own unique flavor profile and a touch of moisture thanks to that molasses content.

Using Coconut Sugar as a Substitute: So, how do you make the switch? It’s as easy as a tropical breeze! When your recipe calls for brown sugar, feel free to swap in coconut sugar on a one-to-one basis. However, keep these points in mind:

  • Texture: Coconut sugar tends to be drier than brown sugar. Expect your baked goods to have a slightly different texture—maybe a touch denser or crumblier.
  • Sweetness: Coconut sugar is less sweet than brown sugar. Adjust the amount accordingly in your recipes to hit that perfect sweetness level.

In summary, coconut sugar is a fantastic alternative to brown sugar, especially if you’re looking for a natural twist.

Honey as a Brown Sugar Alternative

Honey, a natural sweetener, offers a more complex taste compared to the caramel-like sweetness of brown sugar. Its floral and fruity undertones can enhance baked goods, sauces, and marinades in unexpected ways. Additionally, honey provides some nutritional benefits, such as antioxidants and a slightly lower glycemic index than brown sugar, making it a more wholesome choice for those mindful of their sugar intake.

When using honey as a substitute, it’s essential to adjust the quantities and other ingredients to maintain the desired texture and sweetness. Since honey is sweeter than brown sugar, you can use less of it. A general rule of thumb is to use about ¾ cup of honey for every cup of brown sugar. Because honey is liquid, you’ll also need to reduce the overall liquid content in your recipe by about ¼ cup for each cup of honey used. This adjustment helps maintain the consistency of your batter or dough, preventing it from becoming too runny.

Also of note, honey’s unique properties affect the texture and browning of baked goods. It tends to retain more moisture, resulting in softer, chewier cookies or cakes. Honey also browns faster than sugar, so it’s advisable to lower your oven temperature by about 25°F to prevent over-browning or burning. For those concerned with honey’s distinctive taste, rest assured that it typically mellows during cooking, blending harmoniously with other flavors in the recipe.

honey as a substitute for brown sugar

Maple Syrup

When substituting maple syrup for brown sugar in baking, there are a few guidelines to follow:

Ratio: For every cup of maple syrup, substitute 1 cup of packed brown sugar. Keep in mind that brown sugar is denser than maple syrup, so it’s essential to pack it firmly when measuring.

Adjust Liquids: Since maple syrup is a liquid sweetener, reduce the amount of other liquids (such as water or milk) by approximately 3 to 4 tablespoons per cup of maple syrup replaced.

Consider Flavor: While brown sugar shares similar caramel notes with maple syrup, it lacks the maple flavor. To enhance the flavor profile of your dish, consider adding a dash of vanilla extract or a pinch of cinnamon when substituting brown sugar for maple syrup.

Feel free to experiment with these substitutions in your baking recipes, and enjoy the delightful flavors they bring! 🍁🧁

Plain White Sugar

In most baking recipes, you can directly substitute white sugar for brown sugar in a one-to-one ratio. So, if your recipe calls for one cup of white sugar, simply swap it with one cup of brown sugar. The sweetness level will remain the same, but keep in mind that the texture of your baked goods might change slightly.

However, it’s essential to note that white sugar lacks the molasses content found in brown sugar. As a result, your cookies or other treats may turn out a bit crisper since they won’t have the same moisture typically provided by brown sugar.

white sugar as a brown sugar alternative

✨ Have a look at all our recommended substitutes! ✨

« Previous Post

Need A Vegan Substitute For Heavy Cream? Here’s Our List

Next Post »

Parsley Alternative: What Can Be the Best Substitute for Parsley?

Leave a Comment