Molasses Substitute: Best Substitutes and How to Make Them

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

For an avid baker, molasses is a pantry staple. This dark, thick syrup adds a unique flavor and a rich, caramel-like flavor to a variety of sweet and savory recipes. But let’s face it, we’ve all had that moment when we’re in the middle of whipping up a batch of holiday-ready gingerbread cookies or a sticky barbecue sauce and suddenly realize we’re out of molasses. The good news is that there are plenty of molasses substitutes that can save the day. So, let’s delve into the world of molasses substitute options and how to use them.

Understanding the Molasses Basics

Molasses is a byproduct of the sugar-making process from sugar cane or sugar beets. The sugarcane or sugar beet juice is boiled multiple times, and the thick syrup left after the final boiling is what we know as molasses. There are different types of molasses, like light molasses, dark molasses, and blackstrap molasses, each with a distinct flavor and color. The darker the molasses, the more intense the flavor. Now, let’s take a look at what can serve as an alternative.

A small jar of molasses sits on a countertop

Dark Brown Sugar as a Molasses Substitute

Dark brown sugar is a good substitute for molasses because it has a similar sweetness and a similar color. The sugar crystals in dark brown sugar are coated in molasses, giving it a somewhat similar flavor. To substitute, you can use a one-to-one ratio. So, for every cup of molasses the recipe calls for, you can use a cup of packed dark brown sugar.

Dark brown sugar in a glass bowl

Substituting with Honey

Honey is another great substitute for molasses. It’s a natural liquid sweetener with a similar sweetness and a slightly similar flavor. However, honey has a lighter color and a thinner consistency than molasses. So, while it may alter the final dish’s color and texture, it’s a good alternative when you’re in a pinch. For every cup molasses, use a cup of honey.

This Salted Honey Custard Pie brings a little something different to the Thanksgiving table.

Maple Syrup: A Suitable Molasses Substitute

Maple syrup, a key ingredient in many American recipes, can be a suitable molasses substitute. It offers a similar sweetness, but with a distinctive flavor. It’s thinner than molasses and has a lighter color, so it may change your final product’s texture and appearance. For every cup molasses called for in the recipe, substitute with a cup of maple syrup.


Dark Corn Syrup as a Molasses Substitute

Dark corn syrup can serve as a good molasses substitute because of its high sugar content and dark color. It’s a good option for recipes that require a darker color and a thick, sweet syrup. Substitute a cup of dark corn syrup for every cup of molasses in your recipe.

Using Black Treacle as a Substitute

Black treacle is a good substitute for molasses. It has a distinct, strong flavor that is slightly bitter. This thick, dark syrup is made from sugar cane and has a similar sweetness to molasses. Substitute a cup of black treacle for every cup of molasses in your recipe.

Black treacle in a jar

The Best Approach: Making Your Own

If you’re feeling creative and adventurous, you can make a quick and easy molasses substitute at home. Mix 3/4 cup of white sugar with a 1/4 cup of water and heat it until it forms a sugary syrup. Then, add some extra spices like ginger or cinnamon to mimic the flavor of molasses. While it won’t offer the exact same health benefits as real molasses, it’s a quick swap that can save your recipe.

A sealed jar of molasses

Final Thoughts

Choosing a molasses substitute isn’t a guessing game. It all depends on what you’re cooking or baking, and the flavors you prefer. While no substitute can perfectly replicate the unique flavor and health benefits of molasses, these alternatives can come pretty close. So, next time you’re in the middle of a recipe and realize you’re out of molasses, don’t panic. You have plenty of options to save the day.

« Previous Post

Easy Substitutions for Baking, Cooking & More

Next Post »

Almond Extract Substitute: The Best Replacement Options

Leave a Comment