Half and Half Substitutes: Find the Best Alternatives

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Ever found yourself in the middle of a recipe realizing you’re out of half and half? No need to panic! The good news is there are numerous half and half substitutes you can use instead. Whether you’re looking for dairy products or dairy-free alternatives, this post will guide you through some of the best substitutes for half and half that you can use in your favorite recipes.

Combination of Milk and Heavy Whipping Cream

This make-your-own substitute is a combination of milk and heavy whipping cream. Most dairy products like half and half have a slightly higher fat content, and this combo mimics that perfectly. For every cup of half and half your recipe calls for, use 3/4 cup of whole milk and 1/4 cup of heavy cream.

Milk and Butter

If you need a half substitute in a pinch, a combination of milk and unsalted butter can be a lifesaver. This combo works well because the milk fat in butter adds a creamy texture similar to half and half. For the best results, melt a tablespoon of butter and mix it with enough whole milk to make a cup.

Milk and butter mixture in a glass jug

Sour Cream Can Substitute for Half and Half

Sour cream can be a good stand-in, especially in recipes that require a creamy consistency. However, remember to dilute it with water to match the water content of half and half, as sour cream is thicker. Use an equal amount of sour cream and water for best results.

A bowl of sour cream

Greek Yogurt

Greek yogurt is another dairy product you can use as a half and half substitute. Its creamy texture and slightly tangy flavor can add a unique twist to your favorite recipes. Mix equal parts of Greek yogurt and water to achieve the perfect half and half replacement. You might also have a look at our recommended yogurt substitutes for more ideas.

A bowl of Greek yogurt

Non-Dairy Half and Half Substitutes

If you’re looking for dairy-free options, the good news is there are plenty of half and half substitutes available. From almond milk to coconut milk, these substitutes can provide a creamy texture without the dairy.

Several non-dairy milk products in glass bottles

Coconut Cream as a Substitute for Half and Half

Coconut cream is a fantastic substitute for those on a dairy-free diet. It’s thick, creamy, and has a slightly sweet flavor that can enhance your recipes. Mix equal parts of coconut cream and water to create a dairy-free half and half substitute.

Almond Milk

Almond milk is a popular dairy alternative that can also replace half and half. It’s lighter and has a slightly nutty flavor, making it a great substitute in recipes that don’t require a high fat content. To mimic the creaminess of half and half, mix three parts almond milk with one part olive oil.

Bowl of almonds and a glass of fresh almond milk.

Soy Milk and Olive Oil

Another dairy-free alternative is a combination of soy milk and olive oil. This homemade substitute provides a similar fat content and texture to the real deal. For best results, combine three parts soy milk with one part olive oil.

Have a look at our other ingredient substitution recommendations:

Sage 🌱 Orange Zest 🌱 Jalapenos 🌱 Mint 🌱 Cashews 🌱 Paprika 🌱 Mango

Half and Half Substitute: The Ultimate DIY Sub

In the end, the best half and half substitute depends on your dietary needs and the recipe you’re making. Whether you’re using dairy or non-dairy alternatives, the important thing is to achieve a similar creamy texture and fat content to half and half. So, let your kitchen creativity flow and never fear running out of half and half again!

« Previous Post

Substitute for Baking Soda: Best Baking Powder Substitutes to Use

Next Post »

Whole Milk Substitute: Out of Milk? No Problem!

Leave a Comment